Is short man syndrome a tall story?
Controversy over
short-man syndrome - or the Napoleon complex - has raged for years. Now
scientists say they can finally prove the syndrome exists and that shorter men
are more likely to be jealous husbands and boyfriends than their taller
counterparts.
When glamorous Carla Bruni accompanied her new husband, the French premier, on
an official visit to Britain she made sure she was photographed in nothing but
low-heel shoes. She wasn't tired of tottering on towering stilettoes. No, she
wanted to make sure she didn't overshadow her pint-sized spouse. For Carla is a
good few inches taller than her man - a whole four inches in fact, standing at
5ft 9ins in her stockinged feet while hubby Nicolas Sarkozy is just 5ft 5ins.
Nicolas has followed in the diminutive footsteps of fellow celebs and famous
folks by bagging a tall partner. Just like Rod Stewart, Mick Jagger, Bernie
Ecclestone and Tom Cruise, the president loves to have a taller woman hanging
off his arm. It seems to show that despite his lack of height there are no
shortcomings in other departments - power, charm and wealth to name just three.
But is he just the slightest bit paranoid about his absence of vertical inches?
While Carla's more than content to don frumpy footwear to even out the height
disparity and keep her man happy, he obviously prefers to be proactive and
favours stacked heels. This is not uncommon though among mates of
disproportionate size. Nicole Kidman admitted to never wearing heels when she
was married to former hubby, Tom Cruise and his new wife, Katie Holmes is often
pictured walking behind him to make it look like he's taller than he is. Another
example is statuesque model Sophie Dahl who has abandoned her Jimmy Choos since
dating musician Jamie Cullum, who comes in at just 5ft 4ins.
This whole issue is just part of a wider conundrum about short men which comes
under the banner, surprisingly enough, of 'short-man syndrome'. The notion that
a lot of short blokes compensate for their lack, or perceived lack of height, by
being louder, more aggressive or extra ambitious has been around for centuries.
You only have to look at likes of dictators such as Napoleon, Mussolini, Hitler
and Attila the Hun. All were on the short side, all had mega ambitions to
conquer the world.
Would they have been so bothered if their legs had been a bit longer? Who
knows. Of course, before now there has been no real evidence this syndrome,
sometimes called Napoleon syndrome, actually exists. But now new research seems
to suggest short men are more likely to indulge in bolshie behaviour.
Researchers from the University of Groningen in the Netherlands asked more than
100 men and 100 women how jealous they were in their current relationships and
how interested their partners were in members of the opposite sex. Shorter men
were far more likely to say they were jealous than taller ones. Another survey
undertaken by the National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies in
Paris says short men are unlucky in love when they're younger but go on to form
stronger, longer-lasting relationships later in life.
'I'm still a growing lad - around the waist' THE "Oompa loompas"! -
the name given to me and my best mate by one our less-vertically-challenged
university pals. And this from someone with ears that would give Dumbo more than
a run for his money. Nearly 20 years on, and when we do all meet up, we're still
greeted with "here come the Oompa loompas", swiftly followed by
retorts about situations involving "Noddy" aimed at our tormentor.
Yes, we shorties can come in for a ribbing but there's always a comeback. I've
always been the shortest in groups of friends from early days. Aaaaah, I hear
you cry but I've never felt an overwhelming urge to reach for the platforms or
Cuban stack heels to compensate. To be fair, if I did wear them, I'd probably
get dizzy anyway - I hear the air can get thin past 5ft 5in. Mind you, while
we're on the subject of shoes my wife did wear flats on our wed-ding day but I
can't say it left me with the overwhelming urge to seek therapy. So no, height
really hasn't been an issue for me but vive Nicolas Sarkozy for striking another
blow for we diminutive types when he married Carla Bruni. Yes, interest in
France's first lady almost eclipsed her husband's state visit to the UK but do
you think he was really worried - "Oh no I'm being overshadowed, what will
the UK public think. Hang on a minute, I'm the president of France and married
to one of the most stunning supermodels of the modern era." Things don't
look quite so bad really do they? I'm sure that like me, Mr Sarkozy is perfectly
happy with his height. And although I still like to think of myself as a growing
lad, these days it's the waistline that's doing most of he growing. Maybe it's
time to lay off the Wonka bars for a while. Perhaps the most famous Hollywood
shortie of them all is Tom Cruise who stands at around 5ft 7ins - the
threshold for being classed as a shorter than average man. It has long been
rumoured he wears built-up shoes and is conscious of who he stands next to in
photographs. He doesn't comment on his stature but his ex, Nicole Kidman, said
when they divorced: "I can wear heels now!"
James Bradfield, 5ft 5ins of Welsh band Manic Street Preachers, has a novel way
of dealing with his height. When choosing support bands for their tours he keeps
an eye on how tall the lead singers are before inviting them on the road. He
said: "We had The Enemy on the last tour because there's a strange kind of
symmetry between us and them. "I loved the fact they were so young and they
had come from Coventry - seen as an unfashionable place - but mainly I liked
them because they were all short. "With a Napoleon complex like mine I have
to have a few shorties around to empathise with."
Being among the shortest men in Hollywood never did Danny DeVito any harm. The
five-foot-nothing star of Twins and LA Confidential, is an equally successful
film producer and has been married to Rhea Perlman, Carla from Cheers, since
1982. "Everybody still talks about my height," said Danny.
"They're never going to stop commenting. I think it's great, they call me
the little big man or the dynamic dwarf, I don't get offended at all, it would
be crazy to be offended. "It can only be an asset to be a bit different. In
movie roles I'd rather be the guy who gets to wear the cape and annoy Batman
than the one who has to be nice to girls." Michael J. Fox is another actor
not phased by his small physical stature. He was among the highest-grossing box
office stars in the 1980s starring in the Back to the Future trilogy, Teen Wolf
and Doc Hollywood. "If I were overweight because I ate too much I would
have far more of a complex. I would know if I just stopped eating and showed a
little discipline I would be thin," explained Michael. "But there's
not a hell of a lot I can do about being short. You just gotta run with
it." Measuring up Warwick Davis - actor: 2ft 11ins Gary Coleman - actor:
4ft 8ins Paul Simon - musician: 5ft 2ins Prince - musician: 5ft 2ins Pablo
Picasso - artist: 5ft 4ins Mel Brooks - actor and director: 5ft 4ins Jamie
Cullum - musician: 5ft 4ins Woody Allen - actor and director: 5ft 5ins Napoleon
Bonaparte - French dictator: 5ft 6ins Giving Napoleon complex short shrift.
Peter Dunn, press manager for Warwick University, is 5ft 8ins which would
be regarded as relatively short although not "officially" short. But
he's never been bothered about it. "It's not been an issue for me,"
laughed Peter. "I've never really felt worried about it. My wife is shorter
than me, she's about 5ft 3ins but we have a five-year-old son and he's shooting
up, he'll probably end up taller than me. "Maybe it's a generational
thing." Dr Martin Skinner, a psychology expert at Warwick University, said
it would be a generalisation to label all short men as dissatisfied with their
height and consequently subject to Napoleon syndrome. But he added it was
probably true some men who believed themselves smaller than average might strive
harder or act differently to compensate for their perceived height inadequacy.
Dr Skinner said: "I am sceptical whether anything as coherent as a Napoleon
syndrome exists. "All of us are aware of features we think are inadequate
and features we believe are more than adequate. "But would a short man, who
was not happy being short, strive all the more for success? Possibly but not
necessarily. "I would say in general we all try to compensate for features
we don't particularly like about ourselves." At 6ft Dr Skinner said he
considered himself about average height, or perhaps even a little taller than
average but admitted he had been happy in his youth when he reached that level.
"I think I was in my 20s when the tape tipped over to the 6ft mark and I
remember being very pleased about that," he laughed. "Somehow 5ft 11
and three-quarters was not quite the same."